Isn't it funny how one trip can just really alter your views on food so completely? I left for Italy the type of person who wanted to put sriracha on EVERYTHING and was really happiest when food involved like 100 ingredients.
I came home wanting to eat no more than 10 food items: mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, olive oil, good crusty bread, pasta, salt/pepper, parmesan, balsamic vinegar, and truffles (okay, I know truffles is a bit ridiculous, but they were in season over there and came on just about every dish.) I was also seriously missing the socially acceptable 1/2 bottle of wine at lunch, but I managed to get over that.
What I didn't get over was this salad. I ate some variation of this salad at basically every single meal when we were in Florence, knowing full well that there would never be sweeter tomatoes or fresher mozzarella once I got back home. I managed to come up with a somewhat approximated version of it at Trader Joe's, and then realized that fresh mozzarella is key, so if you have an Italian market nearby that makes their own in-house daily, go that route first!
The sweet saltiness of the balsamic vinegar reduction will make up for any imperfections in the tomatoes.
Sorta-Close-To-Italy Insalata Caprese
for one, and then just keep adding to it for more people
2 really good tomatoes
1 ball of fresh mozzarella - if you're going the trader joe's route for this, get the kind packaged in water
10-12 basil leaves
1/2 cup balsamic vinegar
rresh ground sea salt and cracked pepper
Slice the tomatoes & mozzarella with a serrated knife and layer back and forth. Tuck the basil leaves in between each slice.
Pour the balsamic vinegar into a very small shallow saute pan, heat over medium heat until boiling and then let simmer away until it reduces to about half. Do not walk away from this!!!! Balsamic vinegar reduction goes from syrupy to scorched in the blink of an eye. It's worth it to watch it.
The reduction will thicken up more when it cools. Let it get down to just "warm" and then pour over the entire salad - not too much, you don't want it sitting in a pool, but just enough to wilt the basil leaves a little. Enjoy, preferably with a crusty piece of french bread swiped with a little butter, to sop up the extra balsamic.
